Give The Right One Full Backing
After many years – since the phrase was coined – wondering why the ‘golden generation’ failed to maximise their potential, we 53-years-of-hurt England fans are pretty blessed right now.
When, as at one stage, the nation’s football team is outscoring the nation’s cricket team on a Saturday afternoon, you know something is going right. We have a centre-forward that (nearly) always delivers, Raheem Sterling in the form of his life (and getting better) as well as Sancho and Rashford scrapping for the third attacking role, we are definitely blessed at the goal-scoring end of the pitch. Nineteen goals in four Euro 2020 qualifiers so far have put us in a commanding position to reach and maybe even go all the way in the finals that are as close to a home tournament as it gets.
This week’s match against Kosovo (misleadingly ranked 120th in the world but only accepted into FIFA in 2016) proved that – as an attacking threat – England have rarely been better, scoring five before half-time. At the other end, a concession after just 35 seconds and two second half goals for Kosovo, both following more defensive mistakes, made for a highly entertaining match but asked lots of questions about the defenders at Gareth Southgate’s disposal.
John Stones was a notable absentee this week, but it was his two errors in the Nations League semi-final defeat to The Netherlands that reopened the debate about whether England – despite having such a goal threat – were tight enough to shut out the better teams and thus, get past the likes of France, Germany, Spain and the Dutch when it comes to the crunch next summer.
One area where Southgate is not short of personnel is in the full back positions. For the recent international break he selected the best right back at the 2018 World Cup, Kieron Trippier, and Champions League winner, Trent Alexander-Arnold as his right backs, with arguably the best of the lot, Kyle Walker, left out altogether and £50m Manchester United recruit, Aaron Wan-Bissaka, in the squad until he dropped out injured.
On the left, Danny Rose and Ben Chilwell got a game each while Luke Shaw, once regarded as an England left back for years to come, didn’t get a look in. An embarrassment of riches? On the surface, yes, but we need to be careful it doesn’t lead to just embarrassment.
Full back has long been a feast or famine position for England. In the days when defenders simply defended, we had dependable stalwarts that rarely let the team down. But as the game has evolved and the position has increasingly become key to a team’s game plan, at right back at least, then there have been more ups and downs than Dani Alves on any given match day.
On the left it’s been a relatively secure area as over the last four decades, Kenny Sansom, Stuart Pearce and Ashley Cole amassed 271 caps in total, with able deputies Graham Le Saux and Wayne Bridge also getting more than 70 games between them, although it’s also worth remembering that in-between, we had a right-footed Phil Neville playing there and making a wrong-sided tackle that saw us exit the Euros of 2000.
On the right, if you take out Phil’s brother, Gary, who made eighty-five appearances, then it’s harder to find an accomplished right-sided defender who established himself and made the position their own with distinction (Glenn Johnson, Mick Mills, Phil Neal and Gary Stevens all got around 50 caps) and in major tournaments we have even seen midfielders David Batty, Andy Sinton and Owen Hargreaves play there.
It’s hard to imagine that happening again any time soon. The strength of depth on both sides is astonishing. But if a defence thrives on continuity so that all its components are used to each other, then could it be as much a curse as a blessing?
In the team as much for their attacking ability as defensive attributes, the right and left backs are crucial to modern football success. For an England team that is sweeping through qualification so easily, and with the majority of opponents content to defend deeply, most of the play is in the opposition half where accurate crossing is more valuable than marking and tackling; so is it any wonder that these are the areas where the current full backs (whoever they are on the day) are being found wanting, or leaving gaps that the rest of the team struggle to fill?
Keeping clean sheets has been something of a problem for Southgate of late. Early on in the role, they weren’t, as successive clean sheets against Germany, Brazil and The Netherlands suggested. If anything, the bigger worry then was scoring goals but the emergence of Sterling as a goal machine in addition to the reliability of Kane has taken that problem away.
But comeback goals by Italy and Nigeria in 2018 World Cup warm up games, then conceding to Tunisia and Panama in the finals, despite qualifying from the group comfortably, were a warning sign. In fact, in six games in Russia, only one (v Sweden) saw England’s defence unscathed and the cynic would point to three world-class saves in that game from Jordan Pickford as the reason for that.
Since then, Spain scored four past them in 180 minutes in the Nations League, while Croatia’s sloppy goal at Wembley almost saw England relegated until Kane’s late winner got them to the finals instead, where their playing out from the back ethos was horribly exposed in a semi-final defeat – although that starting XI was shorn of players from the all-English Champions League Final.
In that sense, the depth we have seems ideal. Trippier and TAA out? No big deal, we still have Walker and the rising star of Wan-Bassaka from the under-21s. But there is also a danger that we could easily see a situation where the right-back position changes hands four times in four matches. And that possibly makes us weaker not stronger. So, as difficult as it will be, does Southgate have to make some tough choices now and plump for his #1 Number 2? And then choose an able deputy from the others, leaving the other two to await their turn and simply be victims of playing in an over-subscribed position.
Alexander-Arnold has been a revelation, with speed – of thought and legs – defying his young years and making him seem almost unleaveoutable. But I thought that about Walker too, whose rapid counter attacks and ability to recover problems at the other end, made him an absolute shoo-in at one stage.
And although Trippier endured a tough post-World Cup season after his fantastic performances (and semi-final goal) in Russia, it was hardly a disaster as he played in the biggest game in Europe and then moved to Atletico Madrid to begin a new life under the guidance of defensive-supremo Diego Simone. Quite where this leaves Wan-Bassaka, valued at £50m and like Shaw, playing for the biggest club in the country, but relying on a major injury crisis to get any national team game time, I’m not sure.
I feel ever-so-slightly-qualified to talk about this here, having played at right back myself many years ago. My local and – at the time – best non-league club in the area when I was a teenager had decided to field a youth team in the Midland Floodlit Youth League (that contained the likes of Wolves and Birmingham City) and held open training sessions three days per week so they could select a squad.
Captain and central midfield for my team at the time, I went along and got selected, then played in my usual position during pre-season friendlies. Then when we sat in the changing room for the opening game of the season, I was given the number two shirt. It was a shock and I’d always considered it only one small step up from number 3 “left back – in the changing rooms”. I had no explanation from the manager and I’d not played one moment in that role in my life, but I ended up staying there for a few seasons, some as captain, and made quite a few appearances for the first team too. I actually found it a lot easier than midfield or up front ever was. I had a really clear view of the game, had a bit more time and space than I was used to and could still get forward on occasions; what wasn’t to like? The defending bit was easier too, in those days, as teams played 4-4-2 with an orthodox left winger, so there was never a question of who I was picking up and as long as they weren’t lightning quick (some were; Adrian Littlejohn, I painfully recall, once gave me a twenty-metre head start and still got to the ball first) then I’d be okay. And I had a not-so-secret weapon. If all else failed, I just passed it back to the goalkeeper, who was still allowed to pick it up, and relieved any pressure.
Since Euro 92, that option has no longer been available, and it’s definitely improved and sped up the game after the goal-drought of Italia 90 (although still by favourite World Cup). As a contrast, in 1992, England could barely find a decent, fit right back as they crashed out in the group stage.
In Euro 96’ Terry Venables had Gary Neville as his first – and possibly only choice – right-back; so when he was suspended for the semi-final, England switched from a back-four to a three with Darren Anderton playing a more wing-back role. Similarly, in 1990, central defender Paul Parker had come in for Gary Stevens when the change to three at the back had been made much earlier in the competition.
With the current England team now struck on a back four, where holding midfielders provide cover for the full backs who spend most of their time attacking, not much will change until the next two qualifying rounds (a place in the finals is almost a formality) and the phoney wars that are warm up games are over. The next big and proper test of this England team comes in the summer, when the defence will be exposed to top strikers in competitive games. That’s only gives Southgate eight or nine games before the opening Group D clashes on 14 June (at Wembley, or 15 June at Hampden if we’re really unlucky) to get it right.
With Pickford (despite Kosovo scoring three) looking to have locked down his spot, and Maguire, Henderson, Rice seemingly assured of their places, the rest of the defensive half of the team is up for grabs. At the other end, Kane and Sterling pick themselves and form, injuries and Southgate’s preference on the day, depending on the opponents, will dictate who joins them.
But while it seems like a straight-forward fight between Rose and Chilwell on the left side of defence, the other side feels a little over-crowded right now with the tournament so close. This might leave the players constantly looking over their shoulders and worrying about their place in the squad, rather than working within a back-four on a regular basis to hone their cohesion and understanding before they have to contend with the best Europe has to offer.
So, I urge the boss to act early. He’s worked wonders already, turning a squad that the English fans and press had fallen out with into an extremely likeable and efficient team that has every right to consider themselves amongst the favourites, only four years out of the rubble of that defeat to Iceland.
But if we don’t have a settled defence very soon, my fear is that as soon as we come up against a really strong team – probably in the last 16 or quarter-final when we’re not at Wembley – we might end up right back where we started.
Sorry, that was lame, but it just seemed so obvious.
words Darren Young, D3D4 columnist
]]>