The NY Red Bulls vs. Inter Miami player ratings topic is popular because fans want more than the final score. They want to know who played well, who struggled, and which moments changed the match.
In the 2–2 draw between NY Red Bulls and Inter Miami, both teams had strong individual displays, big defensive mistakes, and young players making a real mark.
Player ratings help turn all of that action into a simple score out of 10.
In this guide, we will break down what player ratings mean, why they matter, who stood out, and what the match tells us about both teams moving forward.
What are Player Ratings in Soccer?
Player ratings are scores given to each player after a match. Most ratings use a 1–10 scale.
A rating is not only about goals. A player can score and still have an average game. A defender can make no headline play but still earn a high score by staying calm, winning duels, and stopping attacks.
Think of player ratings like a school report card for soccer. They give fans a quick way to understand each player’s performance.
Simple Player Rating Scale
| Rating | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 9–10 | Excellent, match-winning display |
| 8 | Very strong performance |
| 7 | Good game with clear impact |
| 6 | Solid but not special |
| 5 | Average or mixed display |
| 4 or below | Poor game or costly mistakes |
Inter Miami Player Ratings vs NY Red Bulls
Inter Miami and NY Red Bulls played out a 2–2 draw in a lively MLS match.
NY Red Bulls started fast. Julian Hall created the opening goal by driving forward and setting up Jorge Ruvalcaba. Miami responded before halftime when Rodrigo De Paul delivered a fine cross for Mateo Silvetti to finish.
In the second half, Lionel Messi helped set up Germán Berterame, who scored his first Inter Miami goal. But the NY Red Bulls did not fade. Hall created another key chance, and Adri Mehmeti finished to make it 2–2.
Miami had more shots and pressure, but Ethan Horvath’s saves helped the Red Bulls leave with a point.
Inter Miami Player Ratings
These ratings are based on match impact, key moments, mistakes, attacking value, defensive work, and overall influence.
| Player | Rating | Quick Breakdown |
| Dayne St. Clair | 6/10 | Could not do much about the goals, but had little else to save. |
| Ian Fray | 8/10 | One of Miami’s better players. Strong runs and useful support in attack. |
| Maxi Falcón | 5/10 | Made some clearances but looked shaky during key Red Bulls attacks. |
| Micael | 5/10 | Struggled with Julian Hall’s pace and movement. |
| Sergio Reguilón | 4/10 | Had a tough time on the flank and offered limited attacking help. |
| Rodrigo De Paul | 7/10 | Great assist for Silvetti, but his defending on the equalizer was poor. |
| Yannick Bright | 6.5/10 | Worked hard in midfield and helped break up play. |
| Telasco Segovia | 8/10 | Pressed well, won the ball, and helped Miami regain control in key moments. |
| Mateo Silvetti | 7.5/10 | Took his goal well and made smart runs into dangerous areas. |
| Lionel Messi | 7/10 | Assisted Berterame and created danger, but missed chances by his high standards. |
| Germán Berterame | 7/10 | Scored an important goal, though he also missed a big early chance. |
| Daniel Pinter | 7/10 | Added energy after coming on and helped Miami press higher. |
| Luis Suárez | 6/10 | Looked dangerous late but did not finish his chances. |
| Javier Mascherano | 5.5/10 | Miami created chances, but defensive gaps again hurt the team. |
Source Note: Ratings are based on match impact, goals, assists, saves, defensive work, and key moments from the game.
Best Inter Miami Player: Telasco Segovia
Telasco Segovia deserves major praise. He did not score, but his work rate gave Miami balance. He pressed hard, won the ball in useful areas, and helped start attacks.
For casual fans, this is a good reminder: not every top performance comes from a goal scorer. Sometimes the best player is the one who keeps the team moving.
Most Important Inter Miami Moment: Berterame’s Goal
Germán Berterame’s goal mattered because it gave Miami a 2–1 lead and eased some pressure on him. He had missed a clear chance earlier, so finishing in the second half was important for his confidence.
Messi’s role in the buildup also showed why defenders cannot switch off around him. Even in a quieter game, he can create one big moment.
Biggest Inter Miami Concern: Defensive Shape
Miami’s back line had problems with speed. Julian Hall caused trouble by running into space and forcing defenders to make quick choices.
When a defense is not organized, one fast attacker can make the whole line look nervous. That happened more than once in this match.
NY Red Bulls Player Ratings
NY Red Bulls did not dominate the ball, but they were sharp when chances came. Their best players made the match difficult for Miami.
| Player | Rating | Quick Breakdown |
| Ethan Horvath | 8.5/10 | Made five saves, including key stops late in the match. |
| Dylan Nealis | 6.5/10 | Stayed alert and helped handle Miami pressure. |
| Robert Voloder | 6.5/10 | Had some tough moments but battled well in the box. |
| Matthew Dos Santos | 6/10 | Worked hard defensively and tried to limit space. |
| Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty | 6.5/10 | Covered ground and helped on the right side. |
| Gustaf Beggren | 6/10 | Kept midfield compact and did the simple things well. |
| Emil Forsberg | 7/10 | Helped set up the late equalizing move with quality delivery. |
| Ronald Donkor | 6.5/10 | Pressed well and added energy in midfield. |
| Jorge Ruvalcaba | 7.5/10 | Took his goal well and showed good movement. |
| Julian Hall | 9/10 | The standout player. Assisted both goals and troubled Miami all match. |
| Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting | 6/10 | Had quiet spells but helped occupy defenders. |
| Adri Mehmeti | 7.5/10 | Scored the equalizer and showed calm in a big moment. |
| Cade Cowell | 6.5/10 | Added speed and helped stretch the game. |
Source Note: Ratings are based on match impact, goals, assists, saves, defensive work, and key moments from the game.
Best NY Red Bulls Player: Julian Hall
Julian Hall was the clear standout for the Red Bulls. He assisted both goals and gave Miami’s defense a very hard night.
His first assist came from direct running and smart decision-making. His second showed patience and awareness in the box. For a young player, that level of calm is impressive.
Hall’s performance is a great example of why assists matter. He did not score, but he shaped the game.
Best Defensive Player: Ethan Horvath
Ethan Horvath played a huge role in the result. Miami had several chances, but Horvath kept the Red Bulls alive with important saves.
Goalkeepers often get judged only when they make mistakes. In this match, Horvath showed how one strong keeper can turn pressure into a point.
Best Young Player Moment: Adri Mehmeti’s Equalizer
Adri Mehmeti’s goal was a big moment because it came late and rescued the draw. Young players can sometimes rush in those situations, but Mehmeti stayed calm.
His finish showed confidence, and his movement into the box was smart. For the Red Bulls, that is a promising sign.
Man of the Match: Why Julian Hall Stood Out
Julian Hall was the man of the match because he had the biggest impact on the game. He assisted both NY Red Bulls goals and kept Inter Miami’s defense under pressure with his pace and smart movement.
Even though he did not score, Hall shaped the match. His direct runs created space, opened passing lanes, and helped the Red Bulls turn limited chances into goals. A 9/10 rating feels fair for his strong all-around display.
Julian Hall stood out because he changed the match without scoring. He assisted both NY Red Bulls goals and kept Inter Miami’s defense under pressure with his speed and smart movement.
- Two assists: He set up both Red Bulls goals.
- Strong pace: He stretched Miami’s back line.
- Smart decisions: He chose the right pass in key moments.
- Big match effect: His play helped Red Bulls earn a 2–2 draw.
Comparing Top Performers from Both Teams
Looking at the key players from NY Red Bulls and Inter Miami highlights the strengths and weaknesses that shaped the match.
For Inter Miami, Telasco Segovia stood out, with Messi contributing an assist, while Berterame and Silvetti were the most effective finishers.
For NY Red Bulls, Julian Hall delivered two assists, and Ruvalcaba and Mehmeti were sharp in front of goal. Goalkeeper Horvath impressed for NY Red Bulls, while St. Clair for Miami had little to do.
NY Red Bulls capitalized on fast counters and high energy, whereas Miami’s main strength was chance creation, though defensive gaps and long periods without the ball affected their overall performance.
| Category | Inter Miami | NY Red Bulls |
| Best player | Telasco Segovia | Julian Hall |
| Biggest star impact | Messi assist | Hall: two assists |
| Best finisher | Berterame / Silvetti | Ruvalcaba / Mehmeti |
| Best goalkeeper | St. Clair had little to do | Horvath was excellent |
| Biggest weakness | Defensive gaps | Long spells without the ball |
| Main strength | Chance creation | Fast counters and energy |
This comparison shows why the match finished. Miami made more chances, but NY Red Bulls were sharper in key moments.
What Analysts and Coaches Said About the Match
After the match, coaches and analysts shared detailed insights on individual performances.
Experts highlighted key players who influenced the game through positioning, tactical decisions, and consistency, rather than just visible stats like goals or tackles.
NY Red Bulls’ midfield was praised for controlling tempo and distributing the ball effectively, while Inter Miami’s forwards were noted for creating intelligent off-ball movement, even when finishing opportunities were limited.
Goalkeepers from both teams were crucial, making saves that shaped the outcome.
Expert Player Ratings:
| Player | Team | Expert Rating | Key Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sean Johnson | NY Red Bulls | 9 | Made several crucial saves, commanded the box well |
| Ronald Matarrita | NY Red Bulls | 8 | Solid defensive positioning, assisted build-up plays |
| Cristian Cásseres Jr | NY Red Bulls | 9 | Controlled midfield tempo, created key chances |
| Omir Fernandez | NY Red Bulls | 7 | Active pressing, missed a few key passes |
| Lewis Morgan | Inter Miami | 8 | Strong attacking runs, excellent off-ball movement |
| DeAndre Yedlin | Inter Miami | 7 | Solid defense, occasional lapses on overlapping runs |
| Robbie Robinson | Inter Miami | 6 | Struggled finishing, contributed to build-up play |
| Ariel Lassiter | Inter Miami | 8 | Created space, good support for forwards |
| Sean Davis | NY Red Bulls | 7 | Defensive work rate high, kept opponents contained |
| Damion Lowe | Inter Miami | 7 | Good positioning, occasional marking errors |
Key Takeaways:
- Experts focus on overall impact, tactical awareness, and decision-making, providing a more nuanced view than just goals or assists
- NY Red Bulls’ controlled midfield and defensive organization gave them an edge, while Inter Miami relied on off-ball movement and counterattacks
- Comparing expert insights to fan discussions can help readers better understand the match dynamics and player contributions
Final Thoughts
The NY Red Bulls vs. Inter Miami player ratings show that this match was not just about the 2–2 scoreline. It was about small moments, smart runs, missed chances, and big saves.
Inter Miami had more of the ball and created enough chances to win, but defensive issues stopped them from closing out the match.
NY Red Bulls showed heart, speed, and belief, with Julian Hall leading the way through two important assists. Ethan Horvath also played a major role by keeping Miami out late.
For fans, player ratings make the match easier to understand because they show who shaped the game and why.
Keep reading match ratings after every game to better understand tactics, player form, and team progress.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who Was The Best Player in NY Red Bulls Vs. Inter Miami?
Julian Hall was the best player overall. He assisted both NY Red Bulls goals and caused major problems for Miami’s defense.
How Did Lionel Messi Play?
Messi had a good game but not a great one by his high standards. He assisted Berterame’s goal and created danger, but he missed chances he usually takes.
Why Did Ethan Horvath Get a High Rating?
Horvath made five saves and stopped important Miami chances late in the match. His saves helped the Red Bulls earn a draw.
Why Did The Match Finish 2–2?
Miami created more chances, but the Red Bulls defended well, took their chances, and got strong performances from Hall and Horvath.
Who Scored in The NY Red Bulls Vs. Inter Miami Match?
Mateo Silvetti and Germán Berterame scored for Inter Miami. Jorge Ruvalcaba and Adri Mehmeti scored for NY Red Bulls in the 2–2 draw.
